How Do You Write a Good Mystery? The Essentials

How Do You Write a Good Mystery?

Do you dream of crafting a thrilling whodunit that keeps readers on the edge of their seats? Writing a captivating mystery novel requires understanding the various subgenres, creating compelling characters, and crafting an intricate plot full of twists and turns.

In this post, I will guide you through the essentials and answer the question: how do you write a good mystery that will have readers eagerly turning the page?

Short Summary

• Determine the subgenre of mystery writing and craft compelling characters with strong motives.

• Strategically plant clues & red herrings throughout your story to keep readers guessing.

• Find a balance between foreshadowing & misdirection for successful mystery writing.

What Kind of Mystery Are You Writing?

Before diving into the world of mystery writing, it’s essential to determine which subgenre your story fits into. The mystery genre is vast, encompassing cozy mysteries, police procedurals, noir detective novels, and suspense mysteries.

Each subgenre offers unique elements and tropes that will shape the foundation of your story. Understanding these distinctions will guide you in crafting a narrative tailored to the expectations of mystery readers, ensuring a truly engaging experience.

Knowing the subgenre of your story will also help you focus on the key elements of great mystery novels, such as compelling characters, tricky twists, and a clever trail of clues. It is essential to understand the character arc of both the victim and the culprit for writing a mystery novel. This can help you explore integral themes in your story.

So let’s delve into the most popular subgenres and see which one suits your story best.

Cozy Mysteries

Cozy mysteries transport readers to quaint small towns, where minimal violence and gore take a backseat to intrigue, suspense, and misdirection. Often found in classic mystery books, these stories feature an amateur sleuth, quirky characters, and a puzzle-solving aspect reminiscent of a murder mystery. The protagonist is typically a woman, appealing to a wide array of mystery readers. For many, their first mystery novel experience is a cozy mystery, sparking a lifelong love for the genre.

With a lighter, comedic tone and a happy, satisfying ending, cozy mysteries provide a comforting escape from the harsh realities of the world. Think of Nancy Drew or Miss Marple, solving crimes in their charming, tight-knit communities.

Police Procedurals

In police procedurals, the focus shifts to the gritty world of law enforcement and the realistic investigation of crimes, usually murders. This subgenre requires extensive research for authenticity, ensuring that the police work and investigative methods portrayed in the story are accurate and believable.

Popular in best-selling crime fiction, police procedurals delve into the inner workings of law enforcement agencies and the tireless efforts of detectives and officers to bring criminals to justice. This subgenre offers mystery writers a chance to explore the complexities of crime-solving in a realistic, grounded manner.

Image by fluxfoto from Getty Images Signature

Noir Detective Novels

Noir detective novels plunge readers into the dark underbelly of urban settings, where morally ambiguous protagonists navigate corruption, decay, and violence. These stories feature flawed characters, intricate plots, and open-ended mysteries, often involving a serial killer or other sinister foes. Classic examples include James M. Cain’s The Postman Always Rings Twice or the hard-boiled detective stories of Raymond Chandler.

With their gritty atmosphere and complex narratives, noir detective novels provide a stark contrast to the lighter tone of cozy mysteries.

Suspense Mysteries

For those craving high-stakes excitement and unexpected twists, suspense mystery stories offer a rollercoaster ride of emotions. A great mystery novel in this genre keeps you guessing until the very end, with clues strategically placed throughout the narrative to guide readers toward the stunning conclusion. A good mystery keeps you engaged and eager for more.

Suspense mysteries often employ red herrings, false leads designed to distract readers and lead them down the wrong path, heightening the thrill of discovery when the truth is finally revealed. This subgenre is perfect for writers who enjoy writing mysteries that keep their readers on their toes, constantly guessing as they navigate a labyrinth of deception and intrigue.

Crafting Compelling Characters

Now that you’ve chosen your mystery subgenre, it’s time to create the cast of characters that will bring your story to life.

In any novel, mystery or not, your characters are the driving force behind the story, and character development is crucial to keeping readers invested in solving the case. From the unique sleuth who serves as the eyes and ears of the story to the believable culprit with a solid motive, your characters should be well-rounded and engaging, drawing readers into their world and the mystery they’re trying to solve.

A well-rounded cast of victims and suspects is equally important for a believable mystery story. By exploring the victim’s relationships with the suspects, you can create a web of intrigue that keeps readers engaged and eager to discover the truth.

Fleshing out these characters and their connections to the crime will add depth to your narrative and make the ultimate resolution all the more satisfying.

The Sleuth

Your detective character serves as the reader’s guide through the mystery, so it’s essential to create a relatable and memorable main character. Give your sleuth idiosyncrasies, interests, and a life outside of the crime to make them a well-rounded and unique character.

Establish their motivation for solving the crime, whether it’s to prevent an innocent person from being jailed, stop the killer from striking again, or achieve a personal goal like a promotion or cash reward.

A compelling and unique sleuth will keep readers engaged and invested in their journey to uncover the truth.

Jack Tuesday by F. Nelson Smith

Buy Now

The Culprit

Crafting a convincing culprit is vital, as the entire plot hinges on their motive for committing the crime. Common motives involve money, passion, or a combination of both. Ensure your culprit’s motive is thoroughly believable, as this will create a solid foundation for the twists and turns of your mystery.

Additionally, consider how this motive affects the culprit’s actions throughout the story, and how they might attempt to cover their tracks or mislead the investigation.

The Victim and Suspects

To create a web of intrigue, flesh out the victim’s relationships with the various suspects. This can involve exploring shared histories, secrets, and motives for wanting the victim harmed.

As you delve into these connections, consider how the suspects’ actions and reactions to the crime may serve to mislead the investigation or cast suspicion on other characters.

By crafting a well-rounded cast of victims and suspects, you’ll keep readers engaged as they attempt to untangle the web of deceit and discover the truth behind the crime.

Plotting Your Mystery Novel

With your characters and subgenre in place, it’s time to plot your mystery novel. This involves establishing the crime, planting clues and red herrings, and structuring the investigation. As you plan your story, consider how the various elements of your mystery will unfold, from the initial crime scene to the final reveal of the culprit. This process will help you build suspense effectively and keep readers engaged throughout the story.

To ensure your mystery unfolds smoothly and logically, it’s crucial to commit to a crime before you begin writing. Plan out what has taken place before hand. This will allow you to drip-feed information bit by bit, keeping readers guessing while providing enough details to keep them engaged.

As you plot your story, consider the various twists and turns your narrative will take, and how these developments will impact your characters and their quest for the truth.

Establishing the Crime

Begin your mystery with a high-stakes crime that captures readers’ attention and sets the stage for the investigation. This often involves introducing the victim, the location of the crime, and the circumstances surrounding the event. As you write a mystery, consider any unusual methods or specific details that could add texture to your story.

For example, the lingering smell left by a specific poison, or the unusual wounds created by an unconventional weapon. These details can serve as crucial clues for your sleuth and add depth to your narrative.

Planting Clues and Red Herrings

Strategically placing clues and red herrings throughout your story is essential to keep readers guessing. Clues should provide hints and information that help readers solve the mystery, while red herrings should mislead them and lead them astray.

As you plant these elements in your story, consider how they will impact the investigation and the reader’s experience. Be careful not to make your clues too obvious, as this can undermine the level of suspense and tension of your story.

Structuring the Investigation

To create a sense of revelation and suspense, follow a classic structure with plot beats that guide your story through the investigation. This includes introducing the mystery, presenting clues and red herrings, and revealing the solution.

As you structure your investigation, consider the pacing of your story and how it will impact the reader’s experience. A well-paced narrative can maintain tension and keep readers engaged, while a slow or disjointed story can frustrate and cost you their interest.

Creating an Immersive Atmosphere

An immersive atmosphere is essential to draw readers into the world of your mystery novel. By choosing the right setting and building tension throughout your story, you can create an engaging and suspenseful narrative that keeps readers invested in the investigation.

Whether your story unfolds in a sleepy seaside town or the gritty streets of a bustling city, the setting can play a crucial role in establishing the tone and mood of your mystery.

Furthermore, building tension and suspense throughout your story is key to keeping readers engaged. By employing techniques such as pacing, cliffhangers, and suspenseful moments, you can create a sense of anticipation and uncertainty that keeps readers on the edge of their seats, wanting to uncover the truth behind the crime.

Choosing the Right Setting

The setting of your mystery novel should be unique and authentic, adding depth to your narrative and enhancing the atmosphere of your story. Whether your tale unfolds in a quaint village or a bustling metropolis, selecting a location that complements the tone and themes of your mystery can make a significant impact on the reader’s experience.

Consider exploring local news sites and other resources to gain insight into the area’s residents, their concerns, and what makes their community unique. This research will help you create a vivid and believable setting that immerses readers in the world of your mystery.

Building Tension

To maintain reader engagement and keep them invested in your mystery, it’s crucial to build tension throughout your story. Techniques such as pacing, cliffhangers, and suspenseful moments can be employed to create a sense of urgency and anticipation.

Pacing controls the flow of the story and can be adjusted to heighten tension, while cliffhangers leave readers reading. Suspenseful moments create a sense of anticipation and mystery, encouraging readers to continue turning the pages.

By skillfully incorporating these elements into your narrative, you’ll create a gripping mystery that holds attention from start to finish.

The Art of Misdirection

Mastering the art of misdirection is essential for any successful mystery writer. This involves finding the right balance between providing clues that help readers solve the mystery and leading them astray with red herrings that keep them guessing.

By developing a keen understanding of how to use foreshadowing and misdirection effectively, you can create a thrilling tale that keeps readers on their toes while maintaining an element of surprise.

Crafting believable red herrings is an essential aspect of misdirection. These false leads should be subtle, plausible, and fit within the context of your story. By developing convincing red herrings that add tension and excitement without feeling forced, you’ll keep readers engaged.

Balancing Foreshadowing and Misdirection

Finding the right balance between foreshadowing and misdirection is crucial for maintaining reader engagement and keeping your mystery novel unpredictable. Foreshadowing involves providing hints and information that will help readers solve the mystery, while misdirection leads them away from the truth and keeps them guessing.

To strike the right balance, ensure that your clues are subtle and not too obvious, while also providing enough misdirection to keep readers invested in the investigation. By carefully balancing these elements, you’ll keep your readers engaged and eager to uncover the truth.

Crafting Believable Red Herrings

Developing convincing red herrings is essential for creating a gripping mystery that keeps readers guessing. These false leads should be plausible, fit within the context of your story, and serve to distract readers from the truth.

To craft believable red herrings, consider how they can be used to mislead the reader and create tension, while also fitting seamlessly into the narrative. By incorporating well-crafted red herrings into your story, you’ll enhance the sense of mystery and excitement.

Revising and Perfecting Your Mystery Novel

Once you’ve crafted your mystery novel, the final step is revising and perfecting your manuscript. This involves seeking feedback from beta readers, who can provide unbiased, third-party insights into your story, and hiring a professional editor to ensure your manuscript is polished and ready for publication.

By carefully reviewing and incorporating the feedback from these sources, you’ll ensure that your mystery novel is free of errors, plot holes, and inconsistencies, making it a truly engaging and immersive experience for readers.

Revising and perfecting your manuscript is not only essential for eliminating errors and inconsistencies, but also for refining your narrative and ensuring that your clues, red herrings, and twists are effectively woven into the story. By diligently revising your mystery novel, you’ll guarantee that your readers are captivated and satisfied with the thrilling tale you’ve crafted.

Beta Readers

Beta readers are invaluable for providing fresh insights and feedback on your manuscript. These individuals, often fellow mystery lovers or writers, can help you identify plot holes, inconsistencies, or unclear passages that you may have overlooked during the writing process.

By carefully considering the feedback from your beta readers and being open to criticism, you can make necessary changes and improvements to your story. To find beta readers who are familiar with your genre and can provide honest, constructive feedback, consider reaching out to online writing communities, such as Goodreads or Reddit, or tapping into your personal connections.

Professional Editing

Hiring a professional editor is essential for ensuring that your mystery novel is polished and competitive in the market. An experienced editor can provide valuable feedback on your manuscript, helping you refine your story, correct errors, and improve clarity and flow.

To find the best editor for your manuscript, seek out professionals who are well-versed in your genre and have a proven track record of successful editing. By investing in professional editing, you’ll ensure that your mystery novel is the best it can be, providing readers with an engaging, suspenseful, and satisfying experience.

Summary

Crafting a captivating mystery novel requires a thorough understanding of the various subgenres, the development of compelling characters, and a carefully plotted and structured narrative. By focusing on these elements and mastering the art of misdirection, you’ll create a gripping tale that keeps readers guessing until the very end.

With the help of beta readers and professional editing, you can refine and perfect your manuscript, ensuring that your mystery novel is a thrilling, immersive experience for readers.

Now it’s time to put pen to paper and begin your journey as a mystery writer. So get to it.

How do you end a thriller?

The perfect ending for a thriller leaves the reader with a sense of satisfaction, closure, and awe. The protagonist should be victorious after overcoming any obstacles, and the story's tension should be resolved in a satisfying way that feels emotionally and logically appropriate. Learn more about crafting a killer ending here.

Next: Ending a Thriller